I have a cold and lately I’ve been sneezing a lot. I mentioned this to Yduj and added how much I enjoyed sneezing… how satisfying I found it. Yduj surprised me when she said that she absolutely looooved a good sneeze too; how it was sort of an orgasm of the nose. I thought about that for a while and realized that she was on to something. And while it’s true that there’s a lot less romance (usually) leading up to a good sneeze, there are some parallels to an orgasm. A sudden rush, a certain feeling of fulfillment. Of course, a big difference is that a sneeze often comes out of the blue whereas with an orgasm you kind of know it’s on the horizon…so it really shouldn’t come as much of a surprise. I guess the analogy is a loose one at best.
For some reason, people will offer “God bless you!”s to perfect strangers whom they hear sneeze in public. As if all of a sudden they’re living in a small town where everyone knows one another. I’ve always thought there’s a certain charm in that ersatz warmth and familiarity and I used to participate in it right up until I became an agnostic. Then, I just found it too awkward to say, “I don’t know for certain if there’s a higher being but in the event there is, God bless you!” That doesn’t just roll off one’s tongue. And when I moved on toward being an atheist (this, after having a friend explain that an agnostic is just a spineless atheist) it became even more unsayable. Imagine, “Although I don’t believe any deities exist or that there’s an afterlife, if I had known you back when I did I would have said, God bless you!” Had I said that, either that stranger would still be running, or more likely, I’d have gotten arrested.
Nowadays when I hear someone sneeze, I’m mute. I know it looks as if I’m being withholding or an asshole, or a withholding asshole, but I don’t “God bless you!” anyone. Not friends, not family, not co-workers…no one. All part of my larger effort to tell the truth. Which is even more noble when you consider that I don’t expect that being virtuous is going to lead to any payoff in a great beyond. Kudos to me!
Obviously, responding to a sneeze with a good old-fashioned, “Gesundheit!” is always a possibility. Nothing about God in that. I’m not sure when or why Americans adopted a German word for a sentiment (good health) that could just as easily been said in English. But I’d bet it was before those two World Wars and the Holocaust. I don’t really think saying ”Gesundheit” is going to be a real option for me. The truth is, I’m still coming around to the idea of possibly buying a German car. So I don’t really see myself going around wishing people well in German, for God’s sake!


January 5, 2012 at 3:52 pm |
was it the angels on the head of a pin thing that led you down this road?
January 5, 2012 at 4:04 pm |
trick question…if there are angels, then who brought then there? nice try!
January 5, 2012 at 3:52 pm |
I work around this very problem by simply saying, “Bless you.”
January 5, 2012 at 4:05 pm |
In which case, I can get a Volkswagen??
January 5, 2012 at 4:19 pm |
Respond to a sneeze with “Volkswagen” and go buy yourself a Ford.
January 5, 2012 at 4:42 pm |
I like that! what can i get if i respond with, “Mercedes”?
January 5, 2012 at 4:41 pm |
i dont say god bless you either. for the same reasons as you (though i defend being an agnostic), but also for another reason as well… if i understand correctly, the need to bless after a sneeze came about due to a belief (now a debunked superstition) that the heart skips a beat upon sneezing… hence the i hope god grants you life after that sneeze bit afterwards.
so really, it’s just an antiquated conceit that no longer needs our attention. i totally do not feel un-polite ignoring a sneeze.
but if you fart out loud, i will say good tidings.
January 5, 2012 at 5:06 pm |
thanks…no, god bless you for the informative remarks.
funny…when i hear a loud fart my heart does skip a beat.
(this is starting to veer into locker room banter….i’m ending it here)
January 15, 2012 at 2:52 pm |
As an atheist myself, I’ve been searching for an appropriate response to the sneeze. Up to now, it’s been a simple “Bless you.” But the word “Bless” also implies a belief in religion and/or God. But now I’ll use the English of Gesundeit: “Your Health,” eliminating the word “Good,” which is another form of “God” as in the word “Goodbye.” (I don’t know which is more demanding, Atheism or Catholicism!)